Provider Provisioned Virtual Private Networks BOF (ppvpn) Thursday, December 14 at 0900-1130 ================================== CHAIRS: Marco Carugi Rich Wilder DESCRIPTION: High Level Overview The goal of this effort is to standardize mechanisms for supporting network-based IP virtual private networks (NBVPN). NBVPNs are distinguished by the following characteristics : 1. Their operations are outsourced to one or more SPs. 2. They may require support for a separate addressing realm for each customer. That is, several customers may use the same IP prefixes, which must be kept distinct for each VPN. 3. They are designed for site to site transport of aggregated traffic. The focus of the WG is the layer 3 mechanisms to be implemented within the service provider infrastructure. Through these mechanisms user interfaces/configurations are simplified and efficiency of resource-sharing and multi-VPN management within provider networks is improved. Other types of VPN service support where the SP infrastructure is totally unaware of the VPN service existence are out of scope of this WG. Devices used for NBVPNs provide independent functions for the customer-facing side and the network-facing side. The customer- facing side has a customer-specific IP forwarding environment, tailored for each customer. The network-facing side of the device participates in the SP network's routing (i.e., runs an IGP and IBGP as a standard router would). Tunnels are used for inter- site connectivity. There are at least 3 different tunneling mechanisms that are considered within the scope of this WG to support NBVPNs: MPLS, GRE and IPSEC. Note that IPSEC can be used as a tunneling protocol itself or an "inner wrapper" within another tunneling protocol such as MPLS or GRE. NBVPNs may also support traditional L2 tunneling protocols at the network-facing side although the use of these tunnels are outside the scope of this working group. A single VPN may make use of a mixture of tunnel mechanisms. Objectives The following are the objectives for the working group. o Engage SPs to further refine service requirements at the customer-facing side which are the basic assumptions for defining the network-facing side functions and MIBs. o Engage SPs to further refine service requirements from a Service Provider perspective. That also includes: - estimate the possible requirements for scale of such services in terms of the number of simultaneous NBVPNs within a SP's network and the number of simultaneous NBVPNs which might be needed between SPs; - estimate the possible requirements for frequency of change for NBVPNs. o Ensure that any proposed technology can meet the estimated scale and frequency of change requirements. o Specify a framework for Network-Based VPNs, including a common terminology and taxonomy. o Take into account IPv4 and IPv6, unicast and multicast and customer sites with either permanent or intermittent connectivity to the service provider. o Define and document existing methods for tunnel multiplexing so that a single tunnel between two devices can be used for tunneling multiple VPNs. o Discuss the applicability of different methods for tunnel associations. The issue of tunnel association includes devices locating other devices that are attached to the same VPN, tunnel formation, and tunnel multiplexing. o Specify statistics and other network management information needed for tunnel operation. For example, to be able to determine when a tunnel's up/down state has changed. o Specify tunnel restoration parameters as required by the specific tunnel technology. o Specify the mechanisms to distribute and populate the customer- specific forwarding environment with local and remote site routes. o Specify the mechanisms that are needed to distribute routes to to each customer's site. o Define methods for inter-AS(SP) VPN interconnect so that VPNs are able to span multiple ASs (SPs). This includes scalability and configurability issues for large numbers of inter-provider NBVPNs. o Define the management of inter-AS(SP) VPN interconnect. This includes scalability and configurability issues for large numbers of inter-provider NBVPNs. o Specify the mechanisms needed for interworking between on demand customer access techniques (ex. IPSEC tunnels) and edge devices providing the NBVPN service. o Specify the security mechanisms to be used to protect the control of NBVPN services and the security mechanisms to protect customer data in NBVPN services. o Identify and specify the technical means for dynamic provisioning of NBVPN. o Specify methods to support VPN-specific SLAs. These includes 1) the use of IntServ or DiffServ capabilities combined with IPSEC, GRE and MPLS, and 2) the use of TE capabilities combined with MPLS QoS. This objective includes both the customer facing side and the network facing side. o Define the MIBs and management framework to be used for configuration and management of NBVPNs on a per-device and per- customer basis. o Coordinate the effort with other organisations working in the same domain (ex. ITU). o Take into account the impact on network operations organizations of dealing with very large scale deployments of MBVPNs. Describe debugging tools and procedures. Define standardized metrics for measuring the performance and heath of NBVPNs. Charter Statement The working group is responsible for defining and specifying the set of mechanisms for supporting network-based virtual private networks (NBVPNs). The work effort will include a framework document, a service requirement document and specific protocol definitions with a focus on scalability and manageability. Scalability and manageability requirements will be based on Service Provider's projections for number, complexity, and rate of change of customer VPNs over the next several years. It is assumed that the effort will produce a limited number of (but likely more than one) solutions. The goal of this effort is to foster interoperable implementations for each of the specific solutions, and commonalities among different solutions to the extent this is practical. Standardization will be gauged on SP support for the specific solutions. The working group will carefully analyze the threat and security aspects of network-based VPNs and define a minimal set of mandatory to implement technologies and management mechanisms to ensure adequate security and privacy of user data in a VPN environment. It is not within the scope of this WG to define new base protocol machinery, such as new routing protocols, new tunneling schemes, or new security mechanisms specific to the NBVPN application. Should the WG require additions or enhancements to existing protocol machinery, the WG will refer requirements to the appropriate WG, rather than undertaking them within the NBVPN WG. AGENDA: Agenda bashing - Co-chairs Message from the AD - Scott Bradner - 10 min Charter introduction (main objectives, milestones) - co-chairs - 10 min Outline for a framework for NBVPN - Callon 10 min (draft-callon-NBVPN-outline-00.txt) Update of a framework for NBVPN - Suzuki/Sumimoto 13 min (draft-suzuki-nbvpn-framework-02.xt) IPSEC VPNs : context and main issues - Gleeson - 10 min Layer 2 VPNs : general introduction (context, main issues) , MPLS-based L2 VPNs - Kompella 15 min (draft-kompella-mpls-l2vpn-02.txt) min Update of the MPLS VPN work at ITU SG13 - Carugi 5 min (see "related ITU work" at //nbvpn.francetelecom.com) OSPF as the PE-CE protocol in BGP/MPLS VPNs - Rosen 10 min (draft-rosen-vpns-ospf-bgp-mpls-00.txt) Using BGP as an Auto-Discovery Mechanism for NBVPN - Ouldbrahim 10 min (draft-ouldbrahim-bgpvpn-auto-00.txt) Update of "NB IP VPN Architecture Using Virtual Routers" - Ouldbrahim 5 min (draft-ouldbrahim-vpn-vr-02.txt) Update of "A Core MPLS IP VPN Architecture" - Muthukrishnan 10 min (draft-muthukrishnan-rfc2917bis-00.txt) BGP/MPLS VPN extension for IPv6 VPN over an IPv4 infrastructure - De Clercq 5 min (draft-nguyen-bgp-ipv6-vpn-00.txt) MPLS/BGP VPN MIB - Nadeau 10 min (draft-nadeau-mpls-vpn-mib-00.txt) Multicast in MPLS/BGP VPNs - Rosen 12 min (draft-rosen-vpn-mcast- 00.txt) Implementing BGP/MPLS VPN in Provider's IP Backbone - Fang 7 min Charter discussion and organization of items to be worked on - Co- chairs - 13 min Mailing list: mailing list at nbvpn@bbo.com , to subscribe email to nbvpn@bbo.com with subscribe as the subject. Mailing archive (and other documentation) at http://nbvpn.francetelecom.com